I'd never heard a convincing case for giving up caffeine, but this could be an interesting one. Has any habitual coffee drinker experimented with stopping? What were the effects?

@bkam what turns medicine into poison is dosage.

For a moderate daily drinker it's probably a good idea to not take it one any caffeine an undemanding day.

@ykgoon Yes worth a try definitely! I'm curious about its impact on creativity.

@bkam I only managed to stop for two days. By the second day I was completely useless, between the headaches and the inability to keep mental continuity.

@machado Haha that's what I'm worried about. I do love the taste as well. But I have gone days without it, maybe not as productive, but not memorably awful either.

@bkam The headaches supposedly go away after a few days/weeks, but now that you made me think about it I'm a bit worried about long term effects. Mainly that it enables bad mental hygiene habits.

@machado How do you mean? Just that it's addictive full stop?

@bkam We already know it enables staying awake longer than you should. It's possible that developing a habit of focusing on things for long periods too often could have adverse long term effects.

@bkam @machado I quit for six months. The first week is brutal. Step down consumption slowly and take something for the headaches. Afterward though I have to say I did not notice a huge difference. I eventually went back to drinking coffee. Though I did drastically lower my overall consumption, 5+ cups per day to 1-2.

@bkam @machado caffeine and other stimulants do put your brain on rails a bit. Maybe the creativity effect is worse if you are sensitive to caffeine.

@bkam stopped drinking coffee before Christmas. Went cold turkey. A couple days of withdrawal but then fine. Now I’m back to drinking it, but only on days when I write and only between 0800 and 1000 (to sync with circadian rhythm). It’s much better. Also of note:

@msweet In what way is it better would you say? I drink 1-3 cups per day probably.

Also, thanks, enjoyed that piece. How's the breathing going?

@bkam I notice the effect more, and I enjoy it more. Instead of being something which I consume mindlessly, I’ve become more deliberate about it. Also discovered I’m less reliant on it than I thought I was.

@bkam When I was younger and not a daily coffee drinker, I would get much more powerful and interesting effects from coffee--borderline psychedelic.

I think limiting to maybe 2 days per week is a good threshold for not developing too much tolerance.

@rustyswarf Yeah I may taper off and do an experiment. I've drunk it since uni really.

@bkam I quit coffee & soda for about 4 months, switched to tea, drank a lot of tea, recently inched back up to about a cup of coffee per day. I have found it extremely hard to quit caffeine entirely. I find it fights fatigue and helps me focus, and I have found it only impacts creativity to the extent that excessive quantities bring on jitters and anxiety.

@richard I agree. It seems to mostly have positive benefits. The past week and a half I've been aiming to write 2000 words per day. I do not find that if I have my first cup of coffee at the 0, 1000, or 2000 word mark makes much difference to how good the writing is, but it does affect how quickly I can do it.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Refactor Camp

Mastodon instance for attendees of Refactor Camp, and members of various online/offline groups that have grown out of it. Related local groups with varying levels of activity exist in the Bay Area, New York, Chicago, and Austin.

Kinda/sorta sponsored by the Ribbonfarm Blogamatic Universe.

If you already know a few people in this neck of the woods, try and pick a handle they'll recognize when you sign up. Please note that the registration confirmation email may end up in your spam folder, so check there. It should come from administrator Zach Faddis.